Hamish Birchall Bulletin
Friday 19th February 2010 - More dodgy DCMS music stats
Questions have been raised in
Parliament about the latest DCMS live music statistics: The questions came in response to a new DCMS report 'Changes in live
music between 2005 and 2009' published on 28 January (link to PDF file
254kb): The report's headline claim is that 'Overall live music is thriving'. Although it acknowledges a fall in attendance at smaller venues, entertainment licensing is ruled out as a contributory factor. There are apparently three reasons for DCMS optimism: the number of live music licences has increased; more adults are going to gigs; and a large increase in the number of professional musicians. But doubts are growing about these claims. Live music licences: Increase in adults attending live gigs: Number of professional musicians: But this is simply wrong. John King, co-founder of the Welwyn and Hatfield Live Music Forum, explained why in a comment posted yesterday beneath Music Week coverage about Lord Clement-Jones' questions: '... DCMS 'statisticians' cherry-picked their live music sector employment statistics from a statistically unreliable survey - 'Music Impact and Footprint' published by the Creative Skills Council. The 50,780 'professional live music musicians' are nothing of the sort, and include 41% part-time musicians and a further 30% employed in ancillary activities (e.g. sound engineers, roadies). But - fatally for the DCMS's argument that this is evidence of a 'thriving' live music sector - this 20% increase in professional employment (even if true) actually relates to the period 2004 to 2006. It appears that DCMS civil servants have misled their own ministers. ' See: http://www.musicweek.com/story.asp?sectioncode=1&storycode=1040108&c=1 Link to Creative & Cultural Skills Council research page (Links to
their two reports under 'Sector', 'Music' 06-07 and 08-09): The CCSC has confirmed that about 30% of the 'live performance' category within these reports represent people who are not musicians, but are in occupations associated with putting on live performance. ENDS Hamish Birchall |